skydereign wrote:sonicforvergame wrote:you should check those pages and i never said to someone that his graphics are bad if i did i would always say after that,that if help is needed i am here for CUZ I know that my graphics would be appreciated
I can easily imply something, without ever stating it. Insisting your graphics are better is one way to do that. And just because knucklecrunchergames or anyone else likes your game, doesn't mean they want you to do their art, especially if you keep insisting.
sonicforvergame wrote:Now those are the TOPICS and PLEASE tell me if it's good
I doubt you really want me to critique your art, last time someone asked me to do this he ended up challenging me, which was rather awkward. Unlike most gE users, I don't really like sugar-coating my critiques. I feel it does the person a disservice. So, don't take any of this the wrong way. But, since you asked... It looks like you rip, scale, and edit the graphics of others. Even if that isn't what you do, it appears that way, making it seem less appealing than it might actually be. For instance, your custom shadow's feat look blurry as if scaled down. If you can make art as good as that shadow almost is, and then leave out a detail like the blurriness of the foot, you don't have much respect for your art. This, as well as you put others' graphics in your "my art free" seem to support that idea (not to mention ripping tiles from mario for Hblade). As for the green hill zone, it is pretty safe for me to assume you are using graphics from official sonic games/high production fan made ones (the tree you originally claimed as your own, you even mentioned it wasn't yours).
Now that elephant you did, sums up the idea that you are scaling existing images down, and editing them. It lacks definition that you would normally find if you drew the image yourself. While that stylistically could be deliberate, your other graphics don't support that idea. You also were making a big deal about how your graphics suck, which usually ends up with people telling you how great they are, and not to beat yourself up. This is an attention trick, and usually good artists, though disliking their own work, don't use it for many different reasons. The people on gE are very lenient and supporting, sometimes to a fault.
So, to sum it up, I don't think your art is good, if it is even really your art. It could be you've just done a poor way of presenting it, and you do have a lot of skill. But for now, I can't see it.
i think .Much people like them and my hd game sonic (i have a topic for it called green hill zone version 0.9 is on) Is HD
and i should not claim other people work as mine
